Family Fitness: Are organic foods better?

Posted by Bert on 3/28/2013 to Family Fitness

The 411 on Organic Foods

Organic foods, non-processed whole foods, raw everything; it’s a rising trend in today’s American culture but does it really make a difference in your health and the health of your loved ones? The cost is higher. In fact just the other day at my local Target grocery store a head of broccoli was $1.29 and the organic head was $2.99. My question has always been whether or not it actually mattered if something was organic or not. I have a lot of friends that are whole food, organic eaters and I trust their decision but the skeptic in me wanted to know if it was just a currently “cool” thing to do or if we should all be doing it because the organic produce was more nutritious.

First off, to understand whether or not organic really is necessary for you and your family we need to know what organic produce means. According to a CNN blog called Eatocracy, organic food is defined as, “…grown without the use of synthetic fertilizers, sewage sludge, irradiation, and genetic engineering, and relies on natural or mechanical methods, rather than prohibited chemicals, for pest control. Simply put - it needs to be as natural as possible.” Since the USDA is a government agency there are certain qualifications that a farm has to pass in order to have their crops considered as USDA certified organic. Also not only does the farm have to be certified but the handlers and processors have to be certified as well! That’s a lot of certification to do which is one of the main reasons why the price is elevated. What I found really interesting is that a farm can still produce organic crops and sell them without the label of “certified organic” as long as their gross income does not exceed $5,000 of organic sales. Meaning what you’re paying for when you buy USDA certified organic is the process of being labeled USDA organic.

What does this mean then when you’re shopping for your produce? And is organic produce more nutritious than conventional produce? According to one major study(actually it’s the first and most reputable study conducted with the intention of answering this question) the answer is yes it does make a difference, however, as with most unconventional trends there are smaller studies that have disproved their findings. “The magnitude of the differences in nutrient levels strongly favored the organic samples. One quarter of the matched pairs in which the organic food contained higher levels of nutrients exceeded the level in the conventional sample by 31% or more,” the report written by author Charles Benbrook explains. It is important to note that this same study was conducted only on tomatoes and did not include any other kind of produce. Another study conducted at Stanford found no patterns that showed organic produce was more nutritious than conventional produce. I could go on and on about the different studies that have been done on this but that wouldn’t be very helpful because it all boils down to the same conclusion that most of them make: there needs to be more data looking at specific nutritional information and the studies need to be conducted for a longer period of time. In fact, that tomato study I mentioned above is one that is supposed to take 100 years before it is complete!

I liked what I read on The Salt, an NPR blog, “…When it comes to their nutritional quality, vegetables vary enormously, and that's true whether they are organic or conventional. One carrot in the grocery store, for instance, may have two or three times more beta carotene (which gives us vitamin A) than its neighbor. That's due to all kinds of things: differences in the genetic makeup of different varieties, the ripeness of the produce when it was picked, even the weather.” The short answer, in my opinion, is that any produce you buy in the grocery store may be more nutritional than another but it doesn’t necessarily have to do with whether or not a crop is organic. If you’re choosing to eat organically because you dislike the pesticides and other chemical agents that may be used on crops of fruit and vegetables that’s great and you should continue to do so if it works for you and your family.

If you’re like me, feeling a little guilty about buying conventional produce so much so that you’re getting to the point where you don’t want to eat any produce for fear that the conventional stuff won’t be nutritious enough and even poisonous or that the price of the organic stuff will eventually break your bank account then stop worrying about whether or not something is organic. It’s still nutritious even if it’s not organic and you should still eat produce and feed it to your kids for the basic nutritional value that’s there.

Also, remember that not every piece of produce that you buy will have a USDA certified organic label but it still may be grown organically. That just means that the farm has decided to forego the lengthy and expensive process of earning that label. Look into having your own garden or buy into a local CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) program. Visit the farmer’s markets in your area and shop for your produce there. Be educated on where your food is coming from and don’t feel like you have to buy the organic label in order for your food to be nutritious!

Bio: Bert is a stay at home mom of two, wife to college sweetheart, and what she calls a "semi-crunchy" mama. After four years of being overweight related to pregnancies, Bert submitted a video entry into a local Biggest Loser type of fitness challenge; she was chosen and lost 25% of her body weight in 90 days. She blogs at FirstTimeMom about everything from cloth diapers, parenting, life and her recent passion with health and fitness.

Comments

Date 3/28/2013
Krista Jones
There are unfortunately loop holes as well in the organic grading. Especially with Dairy. So companies may call themselves organic but are not fully so. http://www.cornucopia.org/dairysurvey/index.html And some brands can label themselves organic but unless it has the USDA stamp it isn't considered officially organic. I personally am not picky. I was blending baby food for my son , fresh spinach leaves, and I found a thing online that said buy organic spinach because it's one of the dirty do
Date 11/13/2013
Scianda
My understanding is that soil quality determines the nutrition value of produce. However, organic produce doesn't have pesticides applied to it, so it is healthier in that regard.
Date 2/1/2015
Theresa Hover
For my family budget, we would have to buy less fresh fruit and veggies, if I only bought organic because of the cost. I think's its better that we eat more fruits and veggies in general, even if they are not organic. Thankfully, where we rent allows me to have a garden space, so this summer, we should have some home-grown organic produce to supplement our diet :) OH and I would never buy organic milk. Organic dairy farms can not use medications to treat their sick cows (yes, organic cows get sick too) and so they either have to continue milking until they're too sick and sent to slaughter, OR most farms will chose to treat the animal, but then it has to be sold to a conventional farm. Organic milk has measurably more inflammatory cells in it (somatic cell count) than conventional milk, due to the fact antibiotics can not be used when mastitis occurs.

Add Comment

Gift Registry

Newsletter - Sign up for our newsletter to be informed of sales and specials!